Policy on the Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence

Menara Perkebunan

1. Purpose and Scope

Menara Perkebunan recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI) tools, including generative AI and large language models (LLMs), are increasingly used in research and scholarly writing. This policy sets out the principles for the responsible and transparent use of AI by authors, reviewers, and editors. It aims to protect the integrity, originality, and confidentiality of the scholarly record. The policy applies to all manuscript types submitted to the journal and to all stages of the editorial and peer-review process.

2. Policy for Authors

2.1 AI tools cannot be authors. AI tools cannot meet the criteria for authorship because they cannot take responsibility for the work, approve the final version, give consent, or respond to questions of integrity and conflicts of interest. AI tools must not be listed as authors or co-authors, or cited as authors.

2.2 Human accountability. Authors remain fully responsible for the content of their manuscript, including any text, data, analysis, figures, or references produced with AI assistance. Authors must carefully review and verify all AI-assisted output for accuracy, bias, fabricated or inaccurate references (“hallucinations”), and potential plagiarism.

2.3 Permitted use. Authors may use AI tools to improve language, grammar, spelling, readability, and formatting, provided that human authors retain control over the intellectual content and substantive conclusions. Such use is permitted under the conditions in this policy, including disclosure.

2.4 Use that is not permitted. Authors must not use AI tools to:

  • generate or substantially write the scientific content, hypotheses, arguments, interpretations, or conclusions of the manuscript without human intellectual contribution;
  • fabricate, falsify, or manipulate research data, results, observations, or citations;
  • create or alter images, figures, photographs, or other visual data (for example, field plots, plant or pest photographs, microscopy, gels, or satellite and remote sensing imagery) in ways that misrepresent the original data. Basic adjustments that do not obscure or remove information are acceptable, provided they follow standard image-integrity practice;
  • paraphrase or rewrite existing published work in order to evade plagiarism detection;
  • generate peer review reports, reviewer responses, or editorial correspondence in place of the author’s own judgment.

2.5 Disclosure. Authors must disclose any use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools in the preparation of the manuscript. The disclosure must appear in a dedicated statement placed before the References section. It should state the name and version of the tool, the purpose of its use, and confirmation that the authors reviewed and take responsibility for the output. For example:

“During the preparation of this work, the author(s) used [name of tool, version] for [specific purpose, e.g., improving language and readability]. After using this tool, the author(s) reviewed and edited the content as needed and take(s) full responsibility for the content of the publication.”

Basic tools that only check spelling or grammar, or reference managers that do not generate content, do not need to be declared. If AI is used as a formal part of the research methodology (for example, machine learning models for yield prediction, image-based disease detection, or remote sensing classification), this is not covered by the statement above. In that case the use must be described in detail in the Methods section, including the model, version, training and validation data, parameters, and the reproducibility of results.

2.6 Data and privacy. Authors must not upload unpublished data, confidential information, or personal data of research participants (for example, farmers or respondents) to AI platforms that do not guarantee confidentiality, and must ensure compliance with applicable data protection and licensing requirements.

2.7 Citation of AI-generated material. AI-generated text, images, or code must not be cited as primary sources. Where AI-generated material is itself the subject of the research, it must be clearly labeled and described.

3. Policy for Reviewers

  • Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers must not upload manuscripts, or any part of them, including figures, data, or the content of their review report, to generative AI tools, because this may breach confidentiality, proprietary rights, and personal data protection.
  • Reviewers must not use AI to generate or write their review. Peer review requires independent human expertise and critical judgment, and reviewers are fully responsible for the content of their reports.
  • Limited use of AI solely to improve the language of the reviewer’s own report is permissible, provided no manuscript content is shared with the tool. Reviewers should disclose such use to the editor.
  • Reviewers who suspect undisclosed or inappropriate AI use in a manuscript should report their concerns confidentially to the editor.

4. Policy for Editors

  • Editors must treat submitted manuscripts and all related correspondence as confidential and must not upload them to generative AI tools.
  • Editorial decisions, including screening, reviewer selection, and acceptance or rejection, must be made by humans and must not be delegated to AI.
  • The journal may use AI-based tools approved by the publisher or editorial office for administrative and integrity checks, such as plagiarism detection, similarity screening, language checks, and image-integrity analysis. Such tools support, but do not replace, editorial judgment. Any concern raised by these tools will be assessed by the editorial team before action is taken.

5. Transparency, Verification, and Misconduct

The journal may request additional information about how AI tools were used, including the prompts, outputs, or underlying data, to verify the integrity of a submission. Failure to disclose AI use, or use of AI in ways prohibited by this policy, will be treated as a breach of publication ethics. Depending on the severity, the Editorial Board may:

  • request correction or clarification from the authors;
  • reject the manuscript at any stage of the process;
  • retract or issue a correction or expression of concern for a published article, following COPE guidelines;
  • notify the authors’ institution or funder, and decline future submissions from the authors concerned.

6. Policy Review

AI technologies and the related ethical and legal frameworks are evolving rapidly. This policy will be reviewed periodically and updated as necessary by the Editorial Board of Menara Perkebunan. Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to consult the latest version at the time of submission or review.

7. Contact

Questions about this policy may be directed to the Editorial Office of Menara Perkebunan.